The Creamer Hotel, located at 304 North Main Street in downtown Mansfield is more than just a building; it’s a living testament to the city’s rich history. It is one of several stops on Saturday’s Secret City Tour; get more information on that event here.
Built between 1887 and 1892, according to Sanborn Fire Insurance Maps, the hotel was strategically situated to accommodate travelers on the Mansfield & Sandusky City Railroad. This railroad company would later become part of the Baltimore and Ohio (B&O) System, a significant player in America’s railroad history.
The hotel’s proximity to Union Station—just 300 yards away—made it an ideal choice for travelers. Its Italianate architectural features, complete with stone quoins and decorative stone banding over the windows, have stood the test of time. Today, the building remains one of the last vestiges of Mansfield’s once-thriving rail area.
Irish Immigrant Turned Hotel Proprietor
Hugh Creamer, born in Ireland in 1870, immigrated to America around 1892. Alongside his brother Peter, he became the proprietor of what was initially known as the DeWert Hotel. The name would later change to the Wyandot Hotel and the Old Hotel Temple before finally settling as Creamers in 1921. Hugh Creamer’s journey from an Irish immigrant to a successful hotel owner is a classic American dream story, one that adds a layer of human interest to the Creamer Hotel’s history.
A Hub During World War II
The 1940s were a transformative period for the Creamer Hotel, coinciding with a surge in railroad business due to World War II. American railways, including the B&O System, were instrumental in the war effort, transporting materials and troops. By 1944, the total railroad volume in the United States had skyrocketed to 783 billion ton-miles of freight and 95 billion passenger-miles. The Creamer Hotel stood as a significant landmark during this period, frequented by GIs and contributing to the 43 million members of the armed forces carried by American railways in 114,000 special troop trains.
The hotel’s fine dining also made it a well-known establishment, not just for transient guests but also for locals looking for an exquisite culinary experience. It became a symbol of stability and resilience, literally the last remaining doorway in all the Flats that GIs frequented during the WWII rush.
The Sole Survivor: A Legacy Preserved
Today, the Creamer Hotel is a relic of a bygone era, a sole survivor in the former rail area of Mansfield. Once surrounded by smaller structures, it now stands alone but not forgotten, with its well-known train mural painted on its north façade. Its history is a tapestry woven from threads of immigration, entrepreneurship, and wartime resilience.
In a world that’s constantly changing, the Creamer Hotel serves as a poignant reminder of Mansfield’s vibrant past, a landmark that has weathered the storms of time and change to tell its unique story.
Google Maps
Image by PublicDomainPictures from Pixabay
